top of page
Search

The Palm Oil Paradox: Is Your Vegan Cookie Killing an Orangutan?

  • Writer: Emanuele Bortolotto
    Emanuele Bortolotto
  • Jul 26
  • 7 min read

Updated: Sep 6


For many, palm oil is the ultimate villain of the food world. It is the shadowy, destructive force responsible for wiping out rainforests and threatening the very existence of the orangutan. To an ethical vegan, its presence in a product can feel like a profound betrayal. How can something be "vegan-friendly" if its production is so deeply entangled with the suffering and death of animals?

But as an investigator, I've learned that things are rarely as simple as they seem. The more I dug into the world of palm oil, the more I discovered a web of shocking paradoxes and uncomfortable truths. It’s a story that challenges our easy assumptions and forces us to ask a very difficult question: what is the truly ethical choice? So today, I’m launching a full-scale investigation into the world’s most controversial, and most misunderstood, oil.


A Portrait of a Paradox: What is this Miracle/Monster Oil?


Before we can judge palm oil, I think it’s important we understand what it is. Palm oil comes from the fruit of the oil palm tree, Elaeis guineensis. These are remarkable, tropical trees that produce a reddish fruit that is incredibly rich in oil.

The single most important fact I discovered in my investigation, the fact that underpins this entire, complicated debate, is this: the oil palm is an absolute freak of nature in its efficiency. It is the overachiever of the plant kingdom, the kid in class who finishes the exam in ten minutes and then asks for extra credit while everyone else is still on question one. An oil palm tree can produce a staggering amount of oil from a very small amount of land.

This incredible productivity is why it has become the most widely consumed vegetable oil on the planet. It is in roughly 50% of all consumer products on supermarket shelves. It’s in your cookies, your crisps, your margarine, your ice cream, your soap, your shampoo, your lipstick. It is the cheap, versatile, and semi-solid fat that powers the modern world.

I mentioned to my editor, that I was investigating palm oil, and he just got a tired, weary look on his face. "Oh, Manu, that one," he said. "Good luck untangling that mess." He was not wrong. Because the same efficiency that makes palm oil a miracle crop is also what has made it an ecological nightmare.


The Case for the Prosecution: The Devastating Impact of Bad Palm Oil


The story of palm oil’s dark side is a grim one. The insatiable global demand for this cheap oil has led to an explosion of oil palm plantations, primarily in Indonesia and Malaysia, and the consequences have been catastrophic.


The Environmental Crime Scene: Deforestation and Biodiversity Loss


This is the charge everyone is familiar with. To make way for these vast monoculture plantations, huge swathes of some of the most biodiverse tropical rainforests on Earth have been cleared and burned.


  • The Scale: Indonesia, for example, has lost millions of hectares of rainforest to palm oil development. This isn't just a few trees; it's an area the size of entire countries.

  • The Climate Bomb (Peatlands): A huge portion of this deforestation occurs on peatlands. Peatlands are swampy, waterlogged ecosystems that store an absolutely colossal amount of carbon in their soil. To prepare them for planting, they are drained and often set on fire. This act releases a "carbon bomb" into the atmosphere, making Indonesia one of the world's largest greenhouse gas emitters. 🔥

  • The Orangutan Crisis: These same rainforests are the last remaining habitat for critically endangered species like the orangutan, the Sumatran tiger, and the Sumatran rhino. The expansion of palm oil plantations is the single biggest threat to their survival. The image of a lone, displaced orangutan stranded in a sea of felled trees has become the heartbreaking poster child for this crisis. It is a genuine, ongoing ecological catastrophe. 🦧


The Human Cost: Labor and Land Rights


My investigation revealed that the environmental toll is only half the story. The palm oil industry has also been widely criticized for its human rights record. Reports from organizations like Amnesty International have documented widespread labor abuses on plantations, including child labor, forced labor, and exposure of workers to toxic pesticides. Furthermore, the expansion of plantations has often involved "land grabbing," where vast territories are taken from Indigenous communities without their consent, destroying their traditional way of life.

After reading all this, the conclusion seems simple, doesn't it? Palm oil is an evil, destructive product, and any ethical person, especially a vegan, should boycott it at all costs. Case closed.

Well, this is where my investigation took a very strange and uncomfortable turn.


The Defense's Surprising Argument: Why a Boycott Could Make Things Worse


As I dug deeper, I encountered a shocking and profoundly counter-intuitive argument, an argument that is now the official position of almost every major environmental organization, from the World Wildlife Fund (WWF) to Greenpeace: a total boycott of palm oil would be a disaster.

This seems insane, right? But the logic is built on that one, inconvenient fact we started with: the freakish efficiency of the oil palm.

I’m going to show you a table of data, and I want you to look at it very carefully. It shows the average global yield of different oil crops, measured in tonnes of oil produced per hectare of land per year.

Oil Crop

Average Yield (tonnes per hectare)

Palm Oil

3.8 tonnes

Rapeseed (Canola) Oil

0.8 tonnes

Sunflower Oil

0.7 tonnes

Soybean Oil

0.5 tonnes

The numbers are staggering. To get the same amount of oil, you need 5 to 8 times more land if you use rapeseed or soy instead of palm.

Now, imagine a global boycott is successful. The massive corporations that make our cookies and soaps still need a cheap, solid fat. They will simply switch to the next most efficient alternative. But to get the millions of tonnes of oil they need, they will have to bulldoze an area of land 5 to 8 times larger to plant it with soy or sunflowers. The result? The deforestation problem doesn't go away; it just gets massively worse and moves to a different part of the world, likely the Amazon basin, the home of the soybean.

This is the "substitution effect," and it is the reason that environmental groups are not calling for a boycott. They argue that palm oil is not the problem; unsustainably produced palm oil is the problem. Their solution is not to run away from palm oil, but to fix it.


The Messy Compromise: A Deep Dive into "Sustainable" Palm Oil (RSPO)


This brings us to the Roundtable on Sustainable Palm Oil (RSPO). The RSPO is a massive, multi-stakeholder organization created to develop and enforce a set of criteria for producing "Certified Sustainable Palm Oil" (CSPO). The idea is to create a market where palm oil can be produced without causing deforestation or harming communities.

This sounds like a perfect solution. But my investigation showed that, like everything in this story, it’s incredibly complicated.


  • The Good: The RSPO is the only global standard for sustainable palm oil that exists. It has set criteria that, when properly enforced, do lead to better outcomes. Supporting companies that are genuinely committed to using 100% certified sustainable palm oil is seen by many as the only viable path forward.

  • The Bad: The RSPO has been widely criticized for being too weak. Critics argue that its standards are not stringent enough, that its auditing processes are flawed, and that many member companies are still engaged in deforestation. It has been accused of providing "greenwashing" for giant corporations.


Questions from the Internet: "So... is palm oil vegan or not?"


This is the question that tears vegan forums apart.

  • Technically: Yes. Palm oil is a plant oil. It contains no animal products. By the strictest, dietary definition, it is vegan.

  • Ethically: This is where the civil war begins. For a pragmatic vegan, supporting Certified Sustainable Palm Oil is the most ethical choice because it is the path that will likely lead to the least amount of total environmental destruction and harm to animals in the long run. For an abolitionist vegan, any connection to an industry that has caused such immense suffering to orangutans and other animals makes the product tainted and unethical, regardless of certification. There is no easy answer.


Questions from the Internet: "How can I avoid unsustainable palm oil?"


This is the practical question. My investigation suggests a few strategies.

  1. Look for the RSPO Label: While not a perfect system, it's the best one we have. Supporting products with a clear RSPO certification is a good start.

  2. Support Companies with Strong Policies: Some companies have gone beyond the RSPO and have their own, more stringent "No Deforestation, No Peat, No Exploitation" policies.

  3. Reduce Processed Foods: The easiest way to avoid palm oil is to eat fewer processed foods. Cookies, crackers, margarine, and many packaged snacks are the biggest users. Cooking with whole foods is the ultimate opt-out.


Internal Link Break!


The entire palm oil debate is a brutal lesson in the complexities of ethical consumerism. It forces a person to ask what the core of their philosophy really is. To understand the foundational ideas that lead to these difficult debates, you have to read my full investigation: [What Is Ethical Veganism?]


The Conclusion: The Uncomfortable Truth


So, after this deep and frankly exhausting investigation, what is the truth about palm oil?

I’ve come to a deeply uncomfortable conclusion. Palm oil is both a miracle and a monster. It is an environmental catastrophe and, paradoxically, our best hope for a sustainable vegetable oil supply. The easy, emotionally satisfying answer—to declare it evil and boycott it into oblivion—would, according to the experts I’ve studied, make the problem of global deforestation significantly worse.

The real, difficult, and unsatisfying truth is that we are stuck with it. The solution is not to boycott, but to engage. The answer is to support the brands that are genuinely trying to clean up their supply chains and to put relentless pressure on the ones that aren't. It's to demand a better, stronger, and more transparent system of certification.

It is a "wicked problem" with no simple answers. It’s a reminder that in the complex, interconnected world we live in, the most ethical choice is rarely the easiest one. ✅

Of course, palm oil is just one of many ingredients that can make a technically vegan diet unhealthy if over-consumed. For a broader look at the pitfalls of plant-based eating, check out my field guide: [Can a Vegan Diet Be Unhealthy?]


Sources


Recent Posts

See All

Comments

© 2020 Copyright Emanuele Bortolotto

bottom of page