top of page
Search

Did Going Vegan Make Me Lactose Intolerant? The Great Dairy Betrayal

  • Writer: Emanuele Bortolotto
    Emanuele Bortolotto
  • Jul 22
  • 8 min read

Updated: Sep 8


I've noticed a strange and fascinating phenomenon, a story I hear time and time again from friends and in online communities. It goes like this: a person decides to go vegan. They spend years diligently avoiding all animal products, thriving on a diet of plants. Then, one day, the inevitable happens. They’re at a party, they’re distracted, and they accidentally eat a piece of vegetarian pizza, not realizing it’s smothered in real mozzarella. Or perhaps, after a moment of nostalgic weakness, they have a spoonful of a friend’s dairy ice cream.

The aftermath, they tell me, is biblical. It’s a level of digestive retribution so swift and so violent, it feels like a personal attack from their own body. It's a shocking experience, especially for someone who used to eat cheese by the block with no issues. This dramatic reaction always leads them to the same baffling, slightly panicked question: "Did I somehow… become lactose intolerant?"


It’s a biological puzzle that I found utterly captivating. Can you actually lose the ability to digest something you once enjoyed without a problem? It seems to defy logic. So, I decided to launch a full-scale investigation to find out the truth. Can veganism cause lactose intolerance? The answer is a wild ride through genetics, human history, and your body’s ruthless efficiency. 🤔


The Scene of the Crime: Deconstructing Dairy


Before I could figure out how a person might lose the ability to digest dairy, I first had to get crystal clear on what's actually happening during dairy digestion. The entire drama boils down to a single sugar and a single, highly specialized enzyme.

  • The Target (Lactose): This is the sugar that is naturally found in milk and dairy products. From a molecular perspective, it’s a disaccharide, meaning it's made of two smaller sugar molecules (glucose and galactose) that are linked together. I like to think of lactose as a complex, encrypted data file. It’s full of valuable energy, but your body can’t access it until it’s been decrypted.


  • The Software (Lactase): This is the specific and exclusive enzyme that your small intestine produces. Its only job is to be the decryption key for lactose. When lactose arrives, lactase breaks the bond between the glucose and galactose, converting the complex file into two simple files that your body can easily absorb for energy. 💻


  • The System Crash (Lactose Intolerance): This is what happens when you try to open the encrypted lactose file but you don't have the lactase software installed. The file cannot be opened in the small intestine. It travels down to the large intestine, which is like sending a corrupted file to the wrong department. The trillions of bacteria living there are not equipped to decrypt it properly, so they do the only thing they know how: they ferment it. This fermentation process is chaotic and messy, producing byproducts like hydrogen gas, methane, and various acids. This leads to the classic system crash symptoms: gas, bloating, cramps, and a sudden, urgent need to find a bathroom. 💨

So, this whole mystery isn't really a mystery. It’s a software problem. The real question is: why would a body that once had the lactase software suddenly uninstall it?


Humanity's Bizarre Relationship with Milk: A Historical Detour


To find the answer, I had to go way back. I fell into a fascinating research rabbit hole about human evolution and our very, very weird relationship with dairy. Here’s the most mind-bending fact I learned: being able to digest milk as an adult is not normal. It’s a genetic mutation. Lactose intolerance in adulthood is the original, default setting for the entire human species.

For all other mammals on Earth, and for our own ancient ancestors, the gene that tells the body to produce lactase effectively switches off after an infant is weaned. This makes perfect biological sense. Milk is for babies. Once an animal (or human) moves on to solid food, the body logically stops wasting precious resources producing an enzyme for a food it will never consume again. For the vast majority of human history, every single adult on the planet was lactose intolerant.

Then, around 7,500 years ago, somewhere in the fertile plains of Central Europe where dairy farming was taking hold, a random mutation occurred. This mutation kept the lactase gene switched on, a condition we now call lactase persistence. This was an evolutionary game changer. In a world of frequent famine and hardship, these mutant adults had access to a calorie-rich, nutrient-dense superfood that made their non-mutant neighbors violently ill. They had more surviving children, and the gene for lactase persistence spread rapidly.

This genetic story is still visible today. The highest rates of lactase persistence are found in populations with a long history of dairy farming, like those in Northern Europe. This is particularly interesting when you look at a place like Italy. In my research, I found that Northern Italians, with their history of Alpine dairy farming, have a much higher rate of lactase persistence than Southern Italians, whose culinary history is less reliant on fresh milk. It's a living map of our genetic past, told through the story of cheese and evolution. 🧀


The "Use It or Lose It" Hypothesis: I Investigate the Science


Understanding that lactase production is controlled by a gene that is naturally programmed to switch off brings us to the core of our investigation. How does going vegan flip that switch for someone who was previously fine with dairy? The answer, I discovered, lies in a biological principle called downregulation.

Your body is the ultimate efficiency expert. It is constantly monitoring supply and demand and adjusting its production lines accordingly. The expression of your genes—the process of turning a gene's instructions into a functional product like an enzyme—is not always a simple on or off switch. It's often a dimmer switch.

The best analogy I've found in my research is to think of your small intestine as a highly specialized factory. When a person eats dairy regularly, the "Lactase Division" is fully staffed and operational. Every time a shipment of lactose arrives, the workers clock in, the machinery hums to life, and the lactose is processed efficiently.

But what happens when that person goes vegan? The lactose shipments stop. Completely. For the first few weeks, the factory workers in the Lactase Division show up for their shifts, but there’s nothing for them to do. After months and years of no work, the factory manager (the body's regulatory system) makes a perfectly logical executive decision. "We are spending a significant amount of energy and resources maintaining this fully staffed division that has zero workflow. It's inefficient. Let's downsize. We'll lay off most of the workers and mothball the machinery. If a small shipment ever shows up again, maybe we can re-hire a skeleton crew." 🏭

This is downregulation. The lactase gene isn't gone, but the body has turned the dimmer switch way, way down.

Now, fast forward five years. That vegan accidentally eats a slice of cheesy pizza. A massive, unexpected shipment of lactose arrives at the factory. The lone, semi-retired worker on duty looks at the mountain of work, throws his hands up in despair, and the entire shipment gets sent down the line unprocessed. The result is chaos in the large intestine.


Questions from the Internet



Questions from the Internet: "Hold on, is this the same as a dairy allergy? I need to know!"


Let me be extremely clear, because in my research, I found this is the most important and potentially dangerous point of confusion. Lactose intolerance is NOT a dairy allergy. They are fundamentally different, and mixing them up can be a serious mistake.

  • An intolerance is a digestive system problem. It's a mechanical failure. Your body lacks the enzyme to break down a sugar (lactose). The consequences are uncomfortable, unpleasant, and can certainly ruin your day, but they are contained within your gut. They are not life-threatening. 😩

  • An allergy is an immune system problem. It's a case of mistaken identity. Your body's immune system incorrectly identifies a protein in milk (casein or whey) as a dangerous foreign invader, like a virus or a parasite. It launches a full-scale inflammatory attack. This can cause symptoms ranging from hives and swelling to vomiting and, in the worst-case scenario, anaphylaxis—a severe, life-threatening reaction that can close the airways. 🚨

If you experience any symptoms outside of your digestive tract after consuming dairy—like itching, hives, swelling of the lips or throat, or difficulty breathing—you are not dealing with lactose intolerance. You are dealing with an allergic reaction and you need to consult a doctor immediately.


Questions from the-Internet: "Can a former vegan ever regain the ability to digest dairy?"


This is the "can I get my ex back?" question of the digestive world, and the answer is just as complicated. It all depends on your original genetic programming.

If you are someone with the lactase persistence mutation (the Northern European genetic quirk), then yes, it might be possible. Your factory was built for lifelong operation; you just shut it down. By slowly reintroducing tiny amounts of dairy, you can send a signal to the factory manager to start hiring again. This process of upregulation can be slow and uncomfortable, but some people find they can build back a tolerance over time.

However, if you are one of the majority of humans with lactase non-persistence, then your factory was always scheduled for decommissioning after childhood. Your veganism just coincided with the factory's natural shutdown. In this case, trying to re-hire workers is futile. The genetic blueprint says the factory is closed for good.


Internal Link Break!


During my research into digestive issues, the topic of Irritable Bowel Syndrome came up constantly. It's another fascinating case where healthy foods can sometimes cause chaos due to an underlying sensitivity. If that sounds like a familiar struggle, you should read my field report: [Did Going Vegan Give Me IBS?]


Life After Dairy: The Practical Implications


So what does all this mean in practice? If you've been vegan for a while and now find yourself unable to tolerate dairy, the first step is acceptance. Your body hasn't betrayed you; it has simply adapted with ruthless biological efficiency.

Frankly, in my opinion, this is a great opportunity. You are now free to explore the absolutely booming world of vegan dairy alternatives. The quality and variety of plant-based cheeses, milks, yogurts, and ice creams available today are astounding compared to a decade ago. From my research, I’ve found that some of the most impressive dairy-free products are the ones you can make in your own kitchen. For the truly ambitious, my guide on [DIY Vegan Cheese: From Cashews to Cultured Magic] is a great starting point for your new life as a dairy-free wizard. ✨


The Conclusion: An Evolutionary Upgrade


So, let's circle back to our original question. Can veganism cause lactose intolerance? My investigation leads to a clear conclusion: Yes. By removing dairy from your diet for a long period, you can trigger your body to downregulate its production of the lactase enzyme, resulting in a new, functional intolerance.

But I've come to believe that "intolerance" is the wrong word. It implies you've developed a flaw. I propose a rebrand. You haven’t become lactose intolerant; you’ve become biologically normal. You have simply rejoined the majority of humanity and aligned your body with its original, efficient, post-weaning programming.

It's not a bug; it's a feature. Your body didn't break. It just upgraded to a newer, more efficient operating system that no longer requires outdated dairy-based software. And that’s nothing to be scared of. ✅


Sources


Recent Posts

See All

Comments

© 2020 Copyright Emanuele Bortolotto

bottom of page