top of page
Search

Can veganism cause SIBO? A Gut-Wrenching Investigation

  • Writer: Emanuele Bortolotto
    Emanuele Bortolotto
  • Jul 20
  • 6 min read

Updated: Aug 31

I remember the phone call from a friend of mine. She was a few years into her vegan journey and, by all accounts, should have been thriving. "I'm doing everything right," she said, her voice full of frustration and desperation. She was eating mountains of roasted broccoli, giant lentil salads, and bean-packed chilis. On paper, she was a pillar of health. In reality, she confessed, she was so bloated after every meal she looked like she’d swallowed a beach ball. "I feel like my own body is gaslighting me," she lamented. "Why does my digestive system feel so profoundly, aggressively wrong?"

Her story is a tragically common one in the plant-based world. You commit to a diet packed with virtuous, fibrous, wholesome foods, only to be rewarded with digestive chaos. It leads to that panicked, late-night Google search: can veganism cause SIBO?

Her call sent me on my own deep dive. I wanted to understand the science behind this frustrating paradox. Let’s explore what I found and get to the bottom of whether a plant-based diet is a secret gut villain.


What in the World is SIBO? A Ridiculous Metaphor


To understand my friend's plight, we first have to understand SIBO, or Small Intestinal Bacterial Overgrowth. I find it’s easiest to explain by thinking of your gut as a country with different cities and regions.

Your large intestine is a bustling, chaotic metropolis. It's crowded with trillions of tough characters (bacteria) who are experts at breaking down and fermenting tough fibers. It's designed for this kind of rowdy, fermenting party.

Your small intestine, however, is supposed to be the quiet, peaceful countryside. It’s where the delicate work of absorbing vitamins and minerals happens. A few bacteria are supposed to live there, but it should be a relatively calm, low-population area.

SIBO is when a massive, unruly mob from the big city decides to set up a permanent camp in the quiet countryside.

These misplaced bacteria aren’t evil. They’re just in the wrong place at the wrong time. When you send food down—especially their favorite fermentable carbohydrates—they go absolutely wild. Their fermentation party in your small intestine produces huge amounts of gas, which leads to the intense bloating, pain, and discomfort my friend was experiencing.

The real mystery isn't what the mob is eating, but why the guards let them set up camp in the first place. This is where a process called the Migrating Motor Complex (MMC) comes in. Think of the MMC as the night watchmen of your small intestine. Between meals, these guards are supposed to perform a series of powerful, sweeping patrols that push leftover food particles and excess bacteria down into the large intestine. A primary cause of SIBO is a faulty or sluggish MMC. If the guards are lazy or asleep on the job, the mob can move in and take over the countryside.


The Vegan Paradox: When Healthy Food Fights Back


This brings us to the great vegan paradox that had my friend in such distress. The diet she was eating—full of fiber, beans, lentils, onions, and garlic—is scientifically proven to be fantastic for nourishing a healthy and diverse gut microbiome in the large intestine. It’s the perfect food for the big city.

However, when you have SIBO, you are inadvertently dropping this five-star feast right into the lap of the unruly mob camped out in your small intestine. These fermentable foods, known collectively as FODMAPs, are a buffet for these misplaced bacteria. Good digestion should feel like classic cooking from Italy: simple, effective, and joyful. SIBO feels like someone threw the entire pantry into one pot and set it on fire.

This is the most important takeaway for my friend, and for you: her high-fiber, healthy vegan diet did not cause her SIBO. It didn't break her MMC. But it did feed the existing, underlying problem so extravagantly that the symptoms became impossible to ignore. Her diet wasn't the cause; it was the whistleblower.


Questions from the Internet: "So… can a vegan diet actually cause SIBO?"


Let me be unequivocally clear: No. A vegan diet does not cause the underlying physiological dysfunctions that lead to SIBO. It does not damage your gut motility or change the physical structure of your intestines.

What a diet high in plant fibers and FODMAPs can do is act as a diagnostic tool. It can take a low-grade, simmering SIBO problem and amplify the symptoms until you are forced to pay attention. You might have had a sluggish gut for years, but the symptoms were mild on a lower-fiber diet. When you switch to a plant-based diet, you provide so much fuel for these misplaced bacteria that they throw a massive, gas-producing party, and you are left with the painful consequences. It’s a classic case of blaming the messenger who delivered the bad news.


Questions from the Internet: "Do vegans have more gut problems?"


This is a common perception, but it's a bit of a misunderstanding. When someone first transitions to a vegan diet, there is often an "adjustment period" of a few weeks where gas and bloating can increase. This is normal. The microbiome in your large intestine is rapidly shifting as it adapts to a huge influx of fiber. It's like a quiet town suddenly having to handle a massive music festival; things get a bit chaotic before they find a new rhythm.

Over the long term, a well-planned vegan diet is associated with a highly diverse and robust gut microbiome, which is a key indicator of good health. The perception that vegans have more gut problems likely comes from the fact that the diet's high-FODMAP nature can make underlying issues like SIBO and IBS much more symptomatic and obvious, leading those individuals to seek help.


The Vegan SIBO Diet: A Temporary Survival Guide


If you or a friend have been officially diagnosed with SIBO by a doctor, the first step is often a temporary dietary intervention to reduce symptoms. This means following a low-FODMAP diet to starve the overgrown bacteria. This is especially challenging for vegans, but it is entirely possible with careful planning. Remember, this is a short-term therapeutic diet, not a forever lifestyle.

The Mob's Feast (High FODMAP)

Guard-Approved Rations (Low FODMAP)

Onions, Garlic, Cauliflower, Asparagus, Mushrooms

Carrots, Bell Peppers, Zucchini, Spinach, Kale

Beans, Lentils, Chickpeas, Soy Milk

Firm Tofu, Tempeh, Rice, Quinoa (in moderation)

Apples, Mangos, Pears, Watermelon, Peaches

Oranges, Strawberries, Blueberries, Grapes, Kiwi

Wheat, Rye, Cashews, Pistachios

Oats, Peanuts, Walnuts, Pumpkin & Sunflower Seeds




Beyond Diet: Eradicating the Problem for Good


I have to say this with the seriousness it deserves: you cannot cure SIBO with diet alone. The low-FODMAP diet is a symptom management tool. It’s like hiding the food from the mob in the countryside so they quiet down. It doesn't actually get them to leave.

Eradicating the overgrowth is a medical process that must be guided by a doctor. It typically involves:

  1. Eradication Phase: Using specific, targeted antibiotics (like Rifaximin, which works primarily in the small intestine) or a protocol of herbal antimicrobials to reduce the bacterial load.

  2. Prevention Phase: This is the most important part. It involves working with your doctor to address the root cause of why the SIBO happened in the first place. This might mean using a prokinetic agent to stimulate your MMC (get the guards back on their patrol route), addressing low stomach acid, or investigating other underlying conditions.

Please, I urge you, do not try to diagnose or treat SIBO by yourself based on internet articles. Get a proper diagnosis from a gastroenterologist (usually via a lactulose breath test) and create a treatment plan with a professional.


Final Thoughts: Don't Blame the Plants


In the end, I was able to call my friend back with good news. Her diet wasn’t the enemy; it was the loyal friend telling her that something deeper was wrong. She sought out a good doctor, got a proper diagnosis, and started on a path to true healing, all while being able to maintain her vegan lifestyle with some temporary, careful modifications.

So, to answer the question once and for all: can veganism cause SIBO? No. Absolutely not. But it can be the catalyst that makes you finally listen to what your body has been trying to tell you. Your plate of plants isn't the problem; it’s part of the solution to a healthier life. You just have to make sure you're addressing the right problem first.


Sources


Recent Posts

See All

Comments

© 2020 Copyright Emanuele Bortolotto

bottom of page