top of page
Search

Can Veganism cause Diabetes?

  • Writer: Emanuele Bortolotto
    Emanuele Bortolotto
  • Jul 20
  • 7 min read

Updated: Aug 31

I have a strange hobby, which is to occasionally plunge myself into the deepest, darkest corners of the internet's health and wellness communities. It’s a wild place, full of conspiracy theories, questionable advice from shirtless men, and headlines that are scientifically engineered to induce panic. The other day, I saw a real gem: “VEGANS ARE GIVING THEMSELVES DIABETES WITH THEIR HIGH-CARB DIETS!”


I’ll admit, my heart did a little tap dance of anxiety. For a moment, I pictured my pancreas waving a tiny white flag of surrender, utterly defeated by my morning oatmeal. This is a potent and persistent myth, the idea that a diet built on plants—fruits, vegetables, grains—could somehow be the secret cause of a disease defined by blood sugar dysregulation. It feels so counterintuitive that it just might be true, tapping into that deep-seated fear that we’re all doing this whole “health” thing completely wrong.

So, I decided to pull on my metaphorical lab coat and get to the bottom of it. I'm here to investigate the claims, look at the actual science, and answer the question once and for all: can veganism cause diabetes? Or have we been unfairly demonizing the humble sweet potato this whole time?


First, A Crucial Distinction: The Two Faces of Veganism


Before we can even begin to dissect this myth, we have to get two things perfectly straight.

First, we are talking exclusively about Type 2 diabetes. Type 1 is an autoimmune condition where the body attacks its own insulin-producing cells, and it has nothing to do with diet or lifestyle choices. Type 2, on the other hand, is a metabolic condition where the body either doesn’t produce enough insulin or, more commonly, becomes resistant to the insulin it does produce. This is the type that is overwhelmingly influenced by our daily habits.

Second, and this is the most important point in this entire article, we must differentiate between two completely different vegan archetypes. On one hand, you have the “Whole Food Vegan.” This person’s diet is a vibrant tapestry of fruits, vegetables, whole grains, legumes, nuts, and seeds. On the other hand, you have the “Junk Food Vegan.” This person has realized that potato crisps, many gummy sweets, sugary sodas, and white bread are technically free of animal products, and they have built their diet accordingly.

To ask if “veganism” causes diabetes is to miss the point entirely. It’s like asking if “using vehicles” is dangerous. It depends entirely on whether you’re driving a sensible family car or attempting to ride a flaming unicycle down a motorway. The problem is never the category; it's the choices made within it.


What is Insulin Resistance, Anyway? A Ridiculous Metaphor


To understand why a whole-food vegan diet is actually protective against diabetes, we have to understand what insulin resistance is. The science can get complicated, full of talk about glucagon and beta cells. Understanding your metabolism can feel like trying to understand the lyrics of a Nightwish concept album—it's epic, complex, and there's a lot going on with keyboards. But the core idea is actually quite simple.

Imagine this:

  • Your bloodstream is a busy highway.

  • Glucose (sugar) is the cargo being transported on the highway.

  • Your body’s cells are houses along the highway that need this cargo for fuel.

  • Insulin is the delivery driver. The driver has a special key that fits the lock on the front door of every house (the cell’s insulin receptor).

In a healthy person, the insulin driver pulls up, uses the key, unlocks the door, and delivers the glucose package inside the house, where it’s used for energy. The highway stays clear.

In insulin resistance, something has gummed up the lock. The primary culprit is an accumulation of tiny fat particles inside our muscle and liver cells, a condition known as intramyocellular lipids. This fat literally gets in the way of the lock mechanism. Now, when the insulin driver tries to use the key, it doesn’t work properly. The door won't open. The glucose packages can’t get delivered, so they pile up on the highway, causing high blood sugar. In response, your pancreas (the dispatch center) panics and sends out even more insulin drivers to try and get the job done. Over time, this system breaks down, leading to Type 2 diabetes. The key to preventing this is to keep the locks clean.


A Tale of Two Vegans: A Day on a Plate


Let’s see how this plays out with our two vegan archetypes.

A Day in the Life of a Junk Food Vegan:

  • Breakfast: A bowl of sugary cereal with sweetened almond milk. This is like dumping a truckload of packages onto the highway all at once with very few delivery drivers. It causes a massive traffic jam (blood sugar spike).

  • Lunch: A sandwich made with fluffy white bread, processed vegan deli slices, and a side of potato crisps. More refined carbs and processed fats, leading to another, less intense traffic jam.

  • Dinner: A frozen vegan pizza with a highly processed cheese substitute, followed by a pint of dairy-free ice cream. This meal delivers a huge load of refined carbs and saturated fats (from coconut or palm oil), further contributing to the "gum in the locks" of the cells.

This diet, while technically vegan, is a recipe for insulin resistance. It provides all the things that promote the condition and very little of the things that prevent it, like fiber.


A Day in the Life of a Whole Food Vegan:

  • Breakfast: A bowl of oatmeal (a whole grain) with fresh berries and a tablespoon of flaxseed. The fiber in the oats, berries, and flax acts like a series of traffic lights, ensuring the glucose packages enter the highway slowly and steadily. No traffic jam.

  • Lunch: A huge salad with mixed greens, quinoa, chickpeas, roasted vegetables, avocado, and a lemon-tahini dressing. This meal is packed with fiber, protein from the quinoa and chickpeas, and healthy fats from the avocado and tahini. It’s a slow, steady, and nutrient-rich delivery.

  • Dinner: A large portion of lentil soup or a stir-fry with brown rice, tofu, and tons of vegetables. Again, this is a high fiber, high protein, nutrient dense meal that supports stable blood sugar and helps clean out the locks on the cells.

The difference is night and day. The whole-food vegan diet is actively working to improve insulin sensitivity and manage blood sugar, while the junk-food vegan diet is doing the opposite.


Questions from the Internet: "So, let's be clear: can a vegan get Type 2 diabetes?"


Yes, absolutely. As our "Junk Food Vegan" example shows, anyone can increase their risk of Type 2 diabetes if they consume a diet high in refined carbohydrates, added sugars, and unhealthy fats, while being low in fiber and essential nutrients. It is not the absence of animal products that matters here; it is the presence of unhealthy, processed foods. The "vegan" label on a cookie does not make it a health food.


Questions from the Internet: "Is it true a plant-based diet can actually reverse Type 2 diabetes?"


This is where the story gets truly exciting. The evidence is overwhelmingly strong that a whole-food, plant-based diet is not just a preventative measure; it's a powerful therapeutic tool. Groundbreaking research by physicians like Dr. Neal Barnard has demonstrated time and again that when people with Type 2 diabetes adopt a low-fat, whole-food vegan diet, they often see dramatic improvements.

Many are able to significantly reduce or even completely eliminate their need for insulin and other medications. By removing the dietary fat that gums up the locks (intramyocellular lipids) and flooding the body with fiber and micronutrients, this way of eating allows the body’s own insulin to start working effectively again. So, far from causing diabetes, a well-planned vegan diet is one of the most effective treatments available for reversing its course.


Internal Link Break!


All this talk about food and complex body mechanics can be a bit much. Sometimes you just want to solve a simple, tangible problem. Like, why the tofu you bought for your healthy stir-fry is so profoundly disappointing. For that, I have a guide: [“Why Does My Tofu Always Taste Like Cardboard?”].


The Verdict: Don't Fear the Fruit


So, let's return to the initial, panicked question. Can veganism cause diabetes? The answer is a resounding no.

That headline you saw online was built on a fallacy. It confused "vegan" with "unhealthy" and "carbs" with "sugar." It ignored the mountain of scientific evidence demonstrating that a diet centered on whole plant foods is one of the most powerful things you can do to protect yourself from Type 2 diabetes. Your body isn't afraid of the carbohydrate in a banana; it's equipped with fiber and nutrients to handle it perfectly. It's the highly processed, fiberless sugar in a bottle of soda that causes the problem.

The power to manage your blood sugar and dramatically reduce your risk of diabetes is not found in avoiding plants. It's found in embracing them in their whole, unprocessed forms. Your oatmeal isn't the enemy. Your bean burrito isn't trying to sabotage your health. The choice is not between meat and diabetes; it’s between whole foods and processed junk.



Sources


Recent Posts

See All

Comments

© 2020 Copyright Emanuele Bortolotto

bottom of page