top of page
Search

Are Vegan Bones Made of Chalk? An Investigation into Dairy-Free Bone Health

  • Writer: Emanuele Bortolotto
    Emanuele Bortolotto
  • Jul 26
  • 8 min read

Updated: Sep 7



It's late on a Saturday night here in Helsinki. The city is quiet, and the sky, even at this hour, still holds a faint, ghostly light. It’s the kind of time when one's thoughts can turn to the big, profound questions of existence. And tonight, I’m thinking about our skeletons. That silent, loyal, and frankly underappreciated scaffolding that stops us all from being just sad, sentient puddles on the floor. 💧

We spend our lives in these bony suits of armor, yet most of us have no idea how they work. We just absorb the one piece of information that has been drilled into our heads by decades of relentless, milk-mustachioed advertising: that the only thing standing between us and a future of spontaneously shattering hips is a constant, lifelong supply of cow’s milk. 🥛

This cultural programming is so powerful that for anyone considering a plant-based diet, a terrifying question inevitably arises. If I give up dairy, will my bones slowly turn to chalk? Will a strong gust of wind pose a serious threat to my structural integrity? Today, as an investigator of our most deeply held beliefs about food, I’m launching a full-scale inquiry. Can a vegan diet support bone health without dairy? Let’s dig in.


A Tour of Your Inner Scaffolding: What Are Bones, Anyway?


Before we can figure out how to feed our bones, I think it’s important to understand what they are. I, for one, always pictured my skeleton as a dry, static, Halloween decoration hanging inside me. But my investigation revealed that this is completely wrong. Your bones are alive. They are dynamic, living tissues, a bustling construction site of constant renewal.

This process is called remodeling. Your body employs two types of highly specialized bone cells in a never-ending cycle of demolition and reconstruction.

  • The Osteoclasts (The Demolition Crew): These are giant cells that wander around your bones, dissolving old, tired bone tissue and clearing it away. It’s like a tiny, internal wrecking ball crew. 🚧

  • The Osteoblasts (The Construction Crew): These are the cells that come in after the demo crew and lay down new, strong, fresh bone matrix. They are the builders.

This process is happening constantly, all over your body. You essentially get a brand-new skeleton every ten years or so. A "strong" skeleton is simply one where the construction crew is working as fast, or faster, than the demolition crew. The goal of a bone-healthy diet is to give your construction crew all the raw materials and support they need to do their job properly.

I was discussing this with my editor, manu, and he made a joke about his own bones being made of 'pure anxiety and coffee,' which, while funny, is not a recognized biological building material according to my research. ☕ So, let's look at the actual materials your builders need.


The Bone Health A-Team: The Nutrients You Actually Need


The marketing campaigns of the last fifty years would have you believe there is only one nutrient that matters for bone health: calcium. And that it only comes from milk. This, I discovered, is a wild oversimplification. Building and maintaining a healthy skeleton requires a whole team of nutrients working in synergy. Calcium is the star player, but it’s useless without its supporting cast.


Calcium (The Bricks 🧱):


Yes, calcium is absolutely essential. It is the primary mineral that gives your bones their hardness and strength. An adult human needs around 1,000 to 1,200 milligrams of it per day. The dairy industry did a brilliant job of convincing us that their product was the only reliable source. But as my investigation shows, the plant kingdom is overflowing with calcium. The trick is knowing where to look and understanding a concept called bioavailability.

  • The Superstars (High-Absorption Sources): The best vegan sources are fortified plant milks (soy, oat, almond) and calcium-set tofu. These are the heavy hitters, often providing as much, or more, calcium per serving as dairy milk. Other champions include leafy greens with low levels of oxalates, like kale, bok choy, and collard greens. Your body can absorb about 50-60% of the calcium from these greens, which is even higher than the absorption rate from dairy milk (around 30%).

  • The Good-But-Not-Greats (Medium-Absorption Sources): Foods like tahini, almonds, and white beans are also good sources of calcium.

  • The Tricky One (Low-Absorption Sources): Spinach is famously high in calcium, but it is also very high in compounds called oxalates, which bind to calcium and prevent your body from absorbing most of it. So, while spinach is incredibly healthy for other reasons, it is not a reliable source of calcium.


Vitamin D (The Chaperone 😎):


You can eat all the calcium in the world, but without Vitamin D, it’s virtually useless. Vitamin D, which is actually a hormone, is the chaperone. Its job is to go to your gut and tell it to open the doors and let the calcium in. Without Vitamin D, your body can only absorb about 10-15% of the calcium you eat. With adequate Vitamin D, that number jumps to 30-40%.

The problem is that there are very few natural food sources of Vitamin D. Our primary source is supposed to be the sun. Our skin is designed to synthesize it from UVB rays. However, for those of us living in northern latitudes (like here in Helsinki), or who wear sunscreen, or who work indoors, getting enough from the sun is nearly impossible for much of the year. This is why Vitamin D supplementation is now recommended by most doctors for almost everyone, regardless of their diet.


Vitamin K (The Director 🎬):


If Vitamin D is the chaperone that gets calcium into the party (your body), then Vitamin K is the director that tells it where to go. Vitamin K activates proteins that help to bind the calcium directly to your bones. It directs the calcium to your skeleton, where you want it. There is also evidence that it helps keep calcium out of your soft tissues, like your arteries, where you don’t want it. The best sources of Vitamin K1 are leafy greens (yes, them again!). Vitamin K2, which may be even more important, is produced by bacteria and is found in fermented foods, most famously in the Japanese dish natto (fermented soybeans).


Protein (The Rebar):


We think of bones as being made of minerals, but about 50% of your bone volume is actually protein. This protein, mostly collagen, creates the flexible matrix or "rebar" into which the calcium minerals are woven. Without a strong protein framework, your bones would be hard but incredibly brittle. A diet that is too low in protein is a major risk factor for osteoporosis. Ensuring you are eating enough protein-rich foods like lentils, beans, tofu, and seitan is crucial for building the underlying structure of your skeleton.


The Acid-Alkaline Hypothesis: A Controversial Detour


During my investigation, I repeatedly came across a controversial but fascinating theory called the acid-alkaline hypothesis of bone health. The idea is that the human body needs to keep its blood pH in a very tight, slightly alkaline range. The theory posits that diets high in animal protein are "acid-forming." To neutralize this acid load, the body pulls the most readily available alkaline mineral it has—calcium—directly from your bones, which is then excreted in the urine. So, according to this theory, a high-meat diet could actually be causing you to pee your bones down the toilet. 🚽

Now, I have to be clear: this theory is highly debated. Many scientists argue that the body has powerful, efficient systems in place to regulate blood pH (like through the kidneys and respiration) and that diet has a minimal effect. They also point out that while protein can cause a slight increase in calcium excretion, it also helps with calcium absorption and is essential for building the bone matrix itself.

My conclusion as an investigator? The direct "acid-ash" effect on bones is likely not as dramatic as some proponents claim. However, the practical advice that comes from this theory—to eat fewer acid-forming animal products and more alkalizing fruits and vegetables—is an excellent strategy for overall health anyway, so it’s not bad advice, even if the reasoning is a bit wobbly.


Questions from the Internet



Questions from the Internet: "Okay, but do vegans break their bones more often?"


This is the big, scary question. And the honest answer, based on my deep dive into the major epidemiological studies, is a nuanced "sometimes, but it depends." The largest study on this, the EPIC-Oxford study, which followed tens of thousands of people for years, did find that vegans had a higher risk of bone fractures, particularly hip fractures.

BUT—and this is a huge but—when the researchers looked closer, this increased risk was primarily seen in vegans who had a low average intake of calcium and protein. Vegans in the study who were consuming enough calcium and protein did not have a significantly higher fracture risk. Another massive study, the Adventist Health Study-2, found no difference in fracture risk between vegans and omnivores. The takeaway from my investigation is this: a poorly planned, low-calcium, low-protein vegan diet can absolutely increase your risk of fractures. A well-planned, nutrient-dense vegan diet that prioritizes these key nutrients does not appear to. The problem isn't the absence of dairy; it's the absence of planning.


Questions from the Internet: "So what is the single best plant milk for calcium?"


This is a great practical question. The first and most important rule is that it must be fortified. Unfortified plant milks are not a good source of calcium. Among the fortified options, I would argue that fortified soy milk is often the winner. Not only does it typically contain the same amount of calcium and Vitamin D as dairy milk (around 300mg of calcium per cup), but it also contains about 7 grams of high-quality protein, which, as we've learned, is also crucial for bone health. Fortified oat and almond milks are also excellent choices for calcium, but they are generally much lower in protein.


Internal Link Break!


A huge part of bone health is getting enough high-quality protein to build the underlying structure. But the world of vegan protein is full of myths and confusion. I've debunked them all in my exhaustive report, which you can read here: [Do Vegans Get Enough Protein Without Eating Meat?]


The Conclusion: You Are Not Made of Glass


So, after this deep dive into the living scaffolding of our bodies, can a vegan diet support bone health without dairy?

My investigation leads me to an unequivocal conclusion: yes, absolutely. The idea that you need to drink the milk of another species to have strong bones is one of the most successful and pervasive marketing myths of all time.

The truth is that you do not need cow's milk for strong bones. You need calcium, you need Vitamin D, you need Vitamin K, and you need protein. And all of these can be easily and abundantly obtained from a well-planned, whole-food vegan diet. It requires a conscious effort. It requires you to make fortified foods your friend, to eat your leafy greens, and to take a Vitamin D supplement. It requires, in short, a plan.

But by building your diet around these key pillars, you can confidently build and maintain a strong, resilient skeleton for life. You are not destined to be a fragile, chalk-boned creature. You are the architect of your own inner scaffolding. 🏗️

Of course, a healthy body also needs a healthy planet, and the environmental arguments for ditching dairy are a whole other story. For a look at that side of the equation, check out my investigation: [Can Veganism Save the Planet?]


Sources


Recent Posts

See All

Comments

© 2020 Copyright Emanuele Bortolotto

bottom of page